Discussion of "On Certainty"
What does it mean to be certain?
Examples of knowledge and belief contexts:
- "I know" (Moore's example) meaning "I can't be wrong"
- 106: Suppose an adult says he's been to the moon.
- "I know" my name 328
- multiplication
Wittgenstein's claims:
553: the queerness of certain "apparent" moves in a l.g.:
"I know I am sitting on a chair"
51-54: basic distinction: Moore's example is not like a hypothesis in
science. Moore's case plays a systemic role in a language game (as in 54)
wheras scientific hyp.s are local.
111: My not having been on the moon is as sure a thing as any grounds
I could give for it.
"Axioms"
- Everything descriptive of a language game is part of its logic.
("there is a red patch" is part of the logic of the l.g.) (56)
- The possibility of a l.g. doesn't depend upon everything being doubted
that can be doubted (392)
- If the true is what is grounded, then the ground is not true, nor yet
false. (205)
- 559