CHAPTER
26
BEING
A CHRISTIAN vs. BEING A MINISTER'S WIFE
Discussions of religion when I was
in Oberlin, meant endless talk about "Is there a God or isn't
there?". It was always easier to be
cynical than pious, to be outrageous rather than stuffy. "Godless Marxism" as exemplified in
I wanted to be a REAL
Christian. I wanted to have a blinding
experience like
Then there was the great deepening
experience after college when I read the Bible, felt the influence of Dr.
Buttrick, and felt some very real answers to prayers, especially in my
marriage.
I never wanted "to marry a
minister" ‑‑ I was simply delighted to be married to someone
who shared my values and who offered me endless ways of sharing the purpose of
his life. And I was proud of
being a minister's wife. I felt I could
honestly support the program of the church and fulfill my need for a deep sense
of purpose. I couldn't think of any
greater purpose than to be teamed with a man who would help people to be
Christians. On our honeymoon Bob found a
copy of Frederick W. Robertson's sermons.
He read several aloud to me, and, though they were published over a
hundred years ago, the ideas seemed fresh and stimulating. Who would have dreamed that reading sermons
on our honeymoon would provide us with a middle name for our third son. Yet it seemed symbolic of the profound part
of our love and friendship for each other that we could be thrilled to grow in
understanding together. (Years later we named our third son "William Robertson"
in his honour.)
It was a privilege to be able to
spend our first year at Union Theological Seminary. The chapel services were conducted by some of
the greatest religious leaders in the country.
"Neo‑ orthodoxy" was in fashion. To me it meant believing the great
traditional truths filtered through the minds of the best scientific minds, an
open ended search for truth. One
believed because it was the truest option one could imagine.
In
Every week Mrs. Morrison had a Bible
class meeting out on a bench in front of her house and I went to it pretty
regularly. It was taught by a 7th Day
Adventist and the women who attended were all pretty poor and ignorant. I soon realized that they loved to talk about
Heaven, the pearly gates, what it would be like when Jesus returned to earth,
etc. Sometimes I felt that it wasn't too
surprising that people who had been so deprived in this life, would be quick to
accept a gospel that promised the tables would be turned. I kept on meeting with them because I was
interested in their problems and sorrows and I wanted to see why they thought
the way they did. I learned how easy it
is to manipulate verses of Scripture to say nearly anything one wants, and to
use the numbers and symbols in the book of Daniel and Revelation to promote
ideas that I was sure were never intended.
Then my father died. February 11, 1948. The phone rang in the middle of the
afternoon. It was my brother Paul in
I was more than 6 months pregnant
and couldn't think of going east. Bob
was so dear and so comforting but for days I felt enveloped in my loss. Most of all I thought of my mother. I couldn't imagine her going on without
Buzz. I wrote to her every day and she
strengthened me by her courage and wisdom.
Bob and I held a little private ceremony for my father at the same time
as his memorial service and that was a comfort too. But the most important thing that happened
was the very strong feeling that Buzz was near me, that he wanted to help me,
that all the most precious qualities, that I had loved so much, could go on,
were going on‑‑somehow even though Buzz had died, that essence
seemed more alive than ever.
Six months earlier if the women in
the Bible group had been talking about life after death and described such an
experience I would have discounted it as wishful thinking. It was wishful thinking, but I suspect all thinking
is somewhat wishful. The fact that these
strong feelings gradually receded does not invalidate them. They say that there is an interval after
death when a person's spirit is still in a state of transition, closer to those
who are still living, and I'd like to believe that, and to believe that my
father, who taught me so much in life, had one further thing to convey even
after his death.
In every church we served I felt
that we had a more sophisticated religion than most of our parishioners. Bob and I were fortunate to have grown up in
such enlightened churches that we could give leadership and guidance. We were both very tolerant of simple souls
who needed rather childish images to support their views, but we saw a
tremendous need to appeal to the backbone of America‑‑the
intelligent searching leadership in each community.
At
While we were at
But the next morning when the doctor
came he told me that coffee wouldn't do that to me. He gave me a mild barbiturate and told me to
rest. The days and nights that followed
were accomplished minute by minute. I
know I was close to a nervous breakdown.
But I was so determined not to fail Bob or our dear little four boys
that I would say to myself, "I will
at least wash the dishes before I break down," or "I will at least
change this diaper before I break down."
I said the 23rd Psalm over and over to myself as I had at the Steins while
the rest were chatting. I had help from
Bob, from Aunt Alice, from Maja and from friends. Bob took Billy to Mrs. Priester and David to
our friend Emma Usinger for one week while I rested up at
Maja told me she had gone through a
very similar experience. She said what
helped her was the realization that she "was doing what she wanted to
do". An old Swedish woman
counseled me that though she had never liked
This experience, painful as it was,
proved to be valuable because it gave me understanding and enabled me to help
other women going through similar crises.
I became aware of how common such experiences are. It took me weeks, months and even years to
recover completely from the anxiety, but I never did have to give up. Mother helped by writing me a wonderful
letter. She told me not even to pray too
much ‑‑ just give in and trust the Lord to help me. So this was a deepening religious experience
too. The biggest insight for me was to
realize that it was my pride (that old‑fashioned but stubborn Christian
sin) that was my undoing. As one of my
When Bob was offered the chance to
become a Methodist and move to Dunsmuir I was appalled. I didn't want to move to Dunsmuir. I didn't want to be a Methodist. Gordon Chadwick had said when we were
children, "The Methodists sing through their noses..." I thought they were low brow. I thought Bob was throwing his career
away. But I was too tired and too
desperately trying to survive each day to argue very effectively. We drove up to look at the parsonage. All Bob saw were the mountains and all I saw
was the barn of a house, hideously decorated.
We stayed at the Oak‑Lo Motel and talked half the night. I gave in.
But looking back I think we had a
more secure life as Methodists. I know
their humor and lack of sanctimoniousness were what appealed to Bob and
me. I think I was more realistic than
Bob in feeling that there would be politics in the
Seven years in Dunsmuir while our
toddlers were developing into school boys were busy years, especially after I
started teaching. But they included wild
beauty ‑‑ majestic
I've been helped by people who
focussed on essentials. Chancellor Tully Knoles of the
While we were at
Frankl liked to quote Goethe saying,
"If you treat people as they are you make them worse ‑‑ if you
treat them as they ought to be you make it possible for them to become what
they are capable of being."
"Say yes to life in spite of everything," was one of
his simple statements that he was able to apply to terminal illness, old age
and other difficulties. This became a
part of my religion. I'll always be glad
that we got to hear Dr. Frankl in person.
I felt he was a gift of God to me.
An experience that still glows in my
mind was the night of our anniversary in 1970.
I was due to go into the hospital the next day for a week's tests to see
if I had a brain tumor or what was causing me to have difficulty in controlling
my right leg. The older four boys were
getting ready for a Sierra hike and there was a mad scramble at home. They didn't seem at all preoccupied with what
had suddenly become a nightmarish worry for me.
Paul at 9 1/2 looked so precious to me and I wanted to be his mother and
raise him! It was hard to suppress
pessimistic thoughts. Bob and I finally
got off for a late dinner at a restaurant at
Most of the high points in my life
are connected with a person. One who
radiated an aura of light and power into my life was Howard Thurman. It happened this way. Bob and I were invited to a District
Ministers' Retreat at St. Elisabeth's ‑ a Catholic retreat center in
I was tired and tense. It was blistering hot when we got there and I
muttered to Dink, "The only women who come to these things are the ones
who are too dumb to have a job..."
And there was Dr. Howard
Thurman. This black, ugly, beautiful man
opened the afternoon session. It would
have been a perfect time to fall asleep, but I did not want to miss a single
word. He spoke of our kinship with all
of life, about how elephants stand silent for a period in the morning and the
evening. No one but Howard Thurman could
make the subject "Elephants and Prayer" meaningful. He mentioned a dog that disappeared every day
at sunset ‑‑ seated himself on a knoll watching the sunset ‑‑
"an eerie, unworldly openness to the dying day."
"The professional tends to be
victimized by love boiled down to a methodology..." One must establish a psychological distance
between himself and involvement. He
cited the example of Hinduism having worked over itself until "the good
was worked out of it with no ethical pull." It became separated from the great agony and
identity with the life that gave it birth.
Buddhism was born to bring back compassion and tenderness. There is a dilemma for the professional who
ritualizes prayer until he isn't ever praying.
He becomes more and more alien to prayer: "I looked everywhere without looking
anywhere." It takes months and
years to let HIM in to certain areas ‑‑ Thurman confessed that
"until the day I die I'll always be trying to impress HIM...once in a
while I'm able to strip."
"There is a tendency to read
about prayer, to study the psychology of prayer, to talk about it, but not to
pray...The prayer life of the religious professional cannot be left to
accident, emergencies: it involves
careful conditioning and training of the nervous system which is the great ally
of the prayer life...One can raise the threshhold of tolerance for
silence." He told of a 6:30 to
8:00 a.m. silent chapel service at a seminary where he was teaching. He assigned his students to write a short
statement on their reactions entitled "What Happened to Me" (during
the meditation). One student wrote seven
or eight pages. Thurman called him in to
his office and handed him the paper torn in pieces saying, "Now go home
and write an honest statement." The
boy was furious but came back humbly a few days later with a paper that
read, "...What in hell am I doing
here? Did I lock my car..."
"Honesty is the hardest thing
in human relations and in prayer,"
Dr. Thurman added. Then he told
the story of Lincoln Steffens' son Peter who knew his father was in great
pain. When a visitor greeted him by
asking the usual "How are you", Steffens had answered,
"Fine."
Peter said, "How come you say
'fine' when you've always taught me to be perfectly honest." Steffens explained, "Well, you see adults
have agreed that on some things we will lie to each other." The courtesy of deception tends to be
carried over into our prayer life.
After dinner the 60 members of the
retreat were crowded into a living room that scarcely held us all. It was still hot enough to make one
perspire. Dr. Thurman stood up holding a
Moffatt translation of the Bible in his hand.
He waited until there was a hushed silence of anticipation. Then he said,
"This evening I'm going to read you the Gospel of Mark." And that is what he did. I am sure there were some ministers who
wished they could escape. I wonder if
there was anyone who was unmoved. He
read unhurriedly for an hour and three‑quarters, and every word had a
special radiance. I cannot explain what
happened in that room, but I was spellbound.
It seemed as if it was an answer to my restless conversation with Bob
earlier in the car.
As luck would have it I was seated
next to Dr. Thurman or across the table from him at three of the meals. I had had such a wonderful conversation with
him at dinner that I edged away the second and third time, but it seemed as if
I was meant to be there. Just to be in
the presence of such a great man was a transcendant experience. I will never forget it.
Shortly after that Bob and I became
involved in a Meditation Group. We
hosted this group for a year. And it did
a great deal for me. For me meditation
was never in conflict with Christianity ‑‑ it was simply spiritual
training, first to concentrate one's attention so that one would not be
distracted, then to open oneself to listen.
One thing I liked about meditation was that one did not have to
perform. One was free to have a high
experience or a shallow experience.
Because our group was not specifically a part of the
At the end of that year we moved to
Grace Church,
When the Burnetts had left, Bob
looked at me and said, "You're going." (The previous spring I had noticed a KQED ad
for a 25 day charter trip to Japan leaving in September and had idly remarked
to Bob, "Let's go." Bob, in a
rare mood of exasperation had told me that I knew we couldn't afford it, and I
had protested that I was only joking anyway.
So it was even more dear of him to immediately chase up the ad and point
out that the flight would leave 4 days hence.)
Bob couldn't possibly go because the Bishop was due for a ceremony to
burn the church mortgage, etc. If the
Burnetts had not delayed us, we would not have received the mail until too late
to do anything about it. It seemed as if
there were many coincidences that made it possible for me to make this special
trip.
As it was we scrambled into the car
to go to
As soon as I had recovered from jet
lag, Keiko wanted to take me to the Meiji Shrine. We took the subway but got off at the wrong
stop so there was a long walk in the misting rain to reach it. I was too proud to tell Keiko that the walk
was too much for me, and as I climbed the knee high stone steps of the Shrine,
I stumbled and fell, dropping and breaking Bob's camera. The film rolled down the wet steps. The huge
holes in my stockings revealed two bloody knees (I would have to spend much of
that 3 weeks on my knees for there were no chairs in Keiko's home nor their
apartment.) I sat there on the wet
steps grimacing in pain as Keiko fluttered over me saying in her limited
English, "Oh Mother, Mother..."
Before I left home I had been
reading Caruthers' book on the Power of Praise which advocated thanking and
praising God for everything, even what seems negative at the time. I was very skeptical of that kind of simplistic
religion, but I couldn't knock its positive approach, so I was saying to
myself, "Thank you God for my bloody knees and the broken camera."
The next morning at breakfast in the
Japanese Inn where I was staying I was brooding over having broken Bob's
camera. "I can't go home without
any visual record of this fascinating experience," I thought.
And then I looked out the window and started to sketch the stone
lantern...the simplest thing I could see.
It was the beginning of my sketching in earnest. I had sketched before but in a totally
haphazard way. Now I had a purpose and
for the first time I was able to submerge my ego which tended to say, "if
you sketch, people will watch you...and they will think, 'does she think she
can sketch?'" I was thinking of Bob
instead of my own unimportant reputation.
The second thing I learned was that all sketches I ever start will look
poor to me at first or at some time along the way. I never sketched in pencil. And I try not to throw any sketches
away. The challenge is to see that
something comes out no matter how poor.
Frequently I would be surprised to look back at what I had done and
think, "well that's not so bad after all."
I also had to confess that this
experience opened several doors. For
three years I had been fighting the neurological problem that made walking
difficult. Even though it was not a
devastating physical handicap, it was a great stumbling block for me. I realized that I didn't mind if other
people limped or stumbled, but I simply couldn't and didn't accept that that
was my fate. Suddenly sketching became
both a symbolic and a very practical example of how closing one door could open
another door. If I kept a sketch book
with me I could always encourage Bob or whoever was with me to go on and hike
the place I could not go, for I would be happy sketching.
I have never quit sketching
completely since then. There are weeks
when I do it much more consistently, especially on vacation or when there are
long meetings. It has whiled away
moments that would have been wasted like sitting in a doctor's office where I
used to fidget...now I could hope the doctor would keep me waiting a little
longer until I finished sketching the old man in the corner or the child in its
mother's arms. A number of times I have
entertained a restless child and given him the sketch. And I have made a number of interesting
casual friends and encouraged a number of young people to follow my example.
I'm reluctant to say that the
experience at the Meiji Shrine was a "religious experience". And yet I believe it was in the best sense. It turned a corner in my simple acceptance of
the fact that there were answers waiting for me. As Viktor Frankl liked to say, "Say YES
to life in spite of everything."
While we were in
My difficulty with labelling
experiences was emphasized soon after we moved to
When the church sent us to
The whole idea of being "turned
on" is fraught with danger. I love
the exhilaration of the high points in my life.
And I have been grateful for experiencing times when I was
ecstatic. But demanding to be
turned on seems phony, whether one uses drugs or manipulation. I feel that one thing that has saved me from
false or hysterical types of experiences (besides common sense) has been a
strong belief that mind, spirit and emotion must work in harmony and humility.
It's still baffling to find myself
struggling with some of the same spiritual problems that haunted me a half a
century ago. But I don't feel negative
about it. Life seems to be for coping
rather than for arriving.